The Mill Creamery

Almost didn't go here because of a couple of bad Google reviews here, but based on a local server's suggestion to try it, we took a chance. It was mid-day, and we had to wait a minute for a server to come from the associated coffee place across the alley, but that was fine... have us a chance to check out the flavors. Unfortunately, they do not allow samples to taste, but again, not a deal breaker. Our single scoops on cones were very good! Vanilla chocolate chip and Moo Cookie. $12 total. Due to the extreme heat outside, we chose to sit inside to eat our sweet treats. Weird that the place seems unfinished or something. Has a ton of cute potential. Unless we just got crazy lucky, don't always trust the reviews here... but you know that already, don't you?

Went there, sign on door basically said no one here to help, go next door so someone at coffee place can help if you want ice cream. We did, a man came over, we looked in the ice cream freezers and saw many of the ice creams with ice frosted over all of the ice cream boxes, like when ice cream is melted and re-frozen again. $7 for a single scoop...not worth the price of such a small serving, approximately a tablespoons worth in size. Asked for a milkshake, the guy said that it was not available when there was clearly a milkshake machine on the counter.

Tasty local ice cream, and a nice owner who thanked us for coming. They do offer samples now, contrary to older reviews