Louie's Pizza

I just don’t understand the hype, or the high rating for that matter. Ordered a regular plain cheese slice last night on the boardwalk for $4.50 (yes $0.75 more per slice than Grotto’s) and I was the only one there. A wrong number was called out, no one came up, then my number shortly after… it was a few teenagers running the takeout section so… yeah.

As you can see from the photo, there is not a drop of tomato sauce on the entire slice; therefore, it tasted near flavorless. Got some garlic and grease in my mouth, then I had to walk across the street to Grotto’s and get their slice of cheese to satisfy my pizza craving. At least it was cheaper. Yep, $4.50 flushed down the toilet.

If you’re looking for a great NY-style cheese slice in Rehoboth you won’t find it on the Boardwalk. Maybe in a few years? This was my second visit, as the first time I tried a slice from Louie’s it was similarly bland. I wanted to give it a second chance due to the high rating (?) and because the place was very busy when I went back in June.

Louie’s is mediocre at best.

Went to Louie’s on Tuesday, July 22 at 5:30pm. Got a table for four in their small indoor dining area which is air conditioned (see picture). There were a number available tables at that time. It got quite busy within 15 minutes after we arrived.

Sabrina was our server and took our order very quickly. We ordered one large pizza (see pic of half the pizza… the slices were gone before I could snap the shot) and two cheese steak grinders. Kids said the grinders were very good.

As for the pizza… is it New York style… no, is it Chicago deep dish… no, is it Rehoboth traditional beach pizza with a nice crispy outer crust, YES!! We love Louie’s pizza and it is very nostalgic for those who have been coming here for years.

Oh, I’ll be back again soon!

20MAY2025 The best service is what I experienced at Louie’s Pizza in Rehobeth Beach, DE. The pizza was the best as the crust, sauce, meat, and cheese where in superb harmony and sooth my taste buds and stomach I the most captivating way. I’ll be back when I’m in town. Love, love, love this spot.