Cuisine
PizzaRecent Reviews
Crust & Craft
Angela Gyuro : 2 on 9/15/2025 2:48 pm
My husband and I were excited to try Crust and Craft after reading so many glowing reviews—unfortunately, our experience fell short of expectations. We ordered the Tempura Cauliflower, the Queen Pizza, and The Killer Bee Pizza. While the flavor combinations and ingredients were fresh and promising, the execution, particularly in terms of cooking, left a lot to be desired.
The Tempura Cauliflower had a delicious sweet heat from the honey-glaze, and jalapeños, and the tempura coating was nicely crispy. However, the cooking was inconsistent—while the smaller pieces were cooked perfectly, the larger ones had the unmistakable crunch and flavor of raw cauliflower, which really detracted from the dish.
The Killer Bee, a pan-style square pizza, was the standout of the night. The balance of hot honey, ricotta, and chili created a unique and flavorful bite that we both enjoyed.
The most disappointing item, sadly, was the Queen Pizza. Despite the use of fresh ingredients, the pizza was extremely soggy, making for a very unpleasant texture overall.
We really wanted to love this place, and there's clear potential here, especially with the creativity of the menu. But unfortunately, the inconsistent preparation made this visit underwhelming.
The Tempura Cauliflower had a delicious sweet heat from the honey-glaze, and jalapeños, and the tempura coating was nicely crispy. However, the cooking was inconsistent—while the smaller pieces were cooked perfectly, the larger ones had the unmistakable crunch and flavor of raw cauliflower, which really detracted from the dish.
The Killer Bee, a pan-style square pizza, was the standout of the night. The balance of hot honey, ricotta, and chili created a unique and flavorful bite that we both enjoyed.
The most disappointing item, sadly, was the Queen Pizza. Despite the use of fresh ingredients, the pizza was extremely soggy, making for a very unpleasant texture overall.
We really wanted to love this place, and there's clear potential here, especially with the creativity of the menu. But unfortunately, the inconsistent preparation made this visit underwhelming.
Angela Gyuro
1757947723
2
5
Crust & Craft
Tiffany DePaoli : 5 on 9/1/2025 9:25 pm
Our first time eating at Crust & Craft was fantastic!
Our server, Luke D., was attentive, friendly and even let my mother know the chilis on the Roni/pepperoni pizza were especially hot so he'd bring them on the side just in case, which was very thoughtful.
For $76 without tip included we had the Roni pizza, Fungi pizza with pepperoni added, Sweet dreams pizza, mozzarella sticks, pineapple upside down cake and one soda. Very fair price for a ton of delicious food! The mozzarella sticks were, hands down, the BEST we'd ever had. The pizzas were generous sizes and we all had leftovers to take home. I'm not a huge pizza fan but they Sweet Dreams is something I will absolutely come back for! The pizzas were excellent; we all loved them.
The restaurant is nicely decorated and may be a little tight when it's busy, but it is wheelchair and stroller accessible. Parking at Midway can be tough but there are parking lots nearby that are about a minute walk away. The restaurant does not take reservations but we were seated right away.
Crust & Craft, see you again soon!
Our server, Luke D., was attentive, friendly and even let my mother know the chilis on the Roni/pepperoni pizza were especially hot so he'd bring them on the side just in case, which was very thoughtful.
For $76 without tip included we had the Roni pizza, Fungi pizza with pepperoni added, Sweet dreams pizza, mozzarella sticks, pineapple upside down cake and one soda. Very fair price for a ton of delicious food! The mozzarella sticks were, hands down, the BEST we'd ever had. The pizzas were generous sizes and we all had leftovers to take home. I'm not a huge pizza fan but they Sweet Dreams is something I will absolutely come back for! The pizzas were excellent; we all loved them.
The restaurant is nicely decorated and may be a little tight when it's busy, but it is wheelchair and stroller accessible. Parking at Midway can be tough but there are parking lots nearby that are about a minute walk away. The restaurant does not take reservations but we were seated right away.
Crust & Craft, see you again soon!
Tiffany DePaoli
1756761932
5
5
Crust & Craft
Christine Gallagher : 5 on 8/24/2025 3:39 am
Gluten free friends, this is the place for good old fashioned pizza (gluten free)! Also had a delicious cocktail! Basil lemon spritz! Refreshing, great flavor and not too sweet. Warm Ricotta dip was a great starter to a great meal (not gluten free but had a spoonful of the dip..delicious!)
Christine Gallagher
1756006789
5
5
Crust & Craft
Modal title